Walking back to my dorm today from class I found myself thinking about my past two trips and the time that I've spent in Istanbul. Being in Paris this past weekend and spending time in a very western state made me miss America so much more than I had since being in Istanbul. You see while I've been in Istanbul everything here is so new and different to me that absolutely nothing reminds me of home. Being in Paris all I could think about was Christmas, my mom, and home because every thing I saw reminded me of those things. Walking back from class today I looked around me and thought about this but also about why we as human beings are constantly fighting and looking for a home- one place where we feel safe and at ease. For centuries empires and states have been fighting for territory or a home for their people. Most recently this is seen in the redevelopment of the Palestinian and Israeli conflict but I saw first hand the repercussions of this fighting on my first trip.
From 1992 to 1995 it can be argued that Sarajevo was the largest Concentration Camp as every citizen and human being in that city was a moving target. Sarajevo was the epicenter of the Bosnian and Serbian conflict in the '90s and today you can still see the bullet holes and bombed buildings even though there has been a huge movement to rebuild. I learned a lot about this conflict in a Class on Genocide I took at Duke last semester. We only got to discuss it briefly but I was fascinated by what happened and before I got to Istanbul said I wanted to go; so this trip meant a lot to me. Flying into Eastern Europe and walking around the city it became clear that this was a place that had gone through a lot. It's a beautiful city and was truly the perfect place for the Winter Olympics but there remains today a sense of quiet suffering which is best seen on the faces of the Bosnian people as you walk by. Our group was immediately hit with that as the guy running our hostel took our bags even though we protested he said, "Don't worry about it, we use to have to carry gallons of water up and down these stairs we are use to it, you probably are not." The siege may have ended in 1995 but there is still clearly a struggle within the people and throughout the city to rebuild and get back to what was their normal life.
As we traveled to Mostar on Saturday this was even clearer. Mostar is a beautiful picturesque townbut walk out of the old city where most of the rebuilding has taken place and you are surrounded by buildings with holes in the walls and others completely destroyed. Living in the US we never have to encounter these kinds of constant reminders of atrocities that happened almost 20 years ago. The largest catastrophe that has happened to us was 9/11 and today just ten years later the area around the World Trade Center is pretty much back to the way it was before 9/11- the towers have been replaced by a beautiful monument and park. We have the economic means and the ability to fix and wipe away what happened. For these Eastern European states it has been very difficult for them to do this and they will probably always have buildings with holes in them.
What's the saddest part of this whole ordeal is that the fighting was all because both sides were looking for or trying to protect their home. The central reason for state building and nationalism is to make people feel at home in their territory. But how can we rationalize the destruction, terror, and blood shed that comes with that?
Being in Paris and a Western nation was a surreal experience for me mainly because I hadn't felt so comfortable in a place since leaving America. If you think about my travels I have spent most of my time going to places I knew were going to be different and uncomfortable for me, but that's exactly why I wanted to go to them. I am at a point in my life where I have the opportunity to go anywhere and see anything. This was the main reason I chose Istanbul.
Paris was absolutely beautiful, everything I had dreamed and more. It was so nice to walk along the streets and the Champs Elysee and not feel people stare at you in wonder. For the first time since being abroad I was able to blend in to the crowd and I felt at ease. Don't get me wrong Istanbul is a beautiful city and I have absolutely loved being here and I do feel safe, but when you are so clearly not a Turk people stare and it makes you feel uneasy. At first it doesn't really bother you but after 3 months of that, it gets old. So Paris was a much needed break from this. My favorite part of my trip besides getting to see my best friends from Duke was definitely the Palace of Versailles. So much history has happened there and walking down the Hall of Mirrors picturing all the different meetings and signings of treaties that happened was an emotional moment for me. In my Diplomatic history course we have learned all the different diplomatic affairs that have taken place since the beginning of the French Revolution so it was so cool to have learned about everything that has happened in Paris and in Europe and then go see where it happened. Again I found myself stopping and really thinking about those treaties and events, and how yes at times they brought groups together but there was always a population left out or looked down upon. The treaties and diplomacy of states are all tactics that nations use to declare what is theirs and where their home is. But again what happens when the minority is trampled on and forced to assimilate. Are they just suppose to try and forget who they are and turn into something else or do they fight for their land?
America is such a unique and young state that it is hard for us to understand the deep connections and ties that bind the different ethnic groups in Europe. Human beings were nomadic people constantly moving around and as tribes developed their only real allegiance was to their immediate family and tribe. This lasted for a long time until empires developed and began taking over lands and asking the nomads to bow down to their will. So now the world was ruled by monarchs but then nationalism rises and the concept of freedom but a connection with a state becomes extremely important. Since this movement we have seen states expand their territory, force other cultures to practice their habits, and uprisings as the other cultures refuse to assimilate. So why must we have states and boundaries? I recognize that this is a lot of rambling and that there are many good things that come with being a part of a state. I guess my main point is if everyone at the end of the day just wants a home and a place they feel at ease then why must we fight and bicker? Why can we not all practice and live our lives the way we want to and not have to feel threatened or fear for our lives. Home is where the heart is and as long as I'm surrounded by people I love and who care about me I can feel at ease; is that enough though? Now I understand that being able to communicate and feel apart of the community is also so important. I think we should all think about what it would be like to be the minority and what it would be like to fear losing your life every day. This is not the answer to all of our problems, but it could be the start of a much better world.
Sending you All my Love from Turkey,
Caroline <3
Oh and I knocked off Switzerland and Germany with our layovers to Paris. So I may have missed Oktoberfest BUT I still got to try some Bratwurst and Beer